Well, Poseidon is strictly Poseidon kids and I think that adding all the minor water kids join wouldn't make it poseidon. And all kids who aren't claimed go to Hermes, and all kids claimed with a minor parent go to Hera, for she has no kids and the minors go there. I don't think they should go to Poseidon cabin 'just because' it would be more like them. It's just not that way. It's been like this for like 6-7 or 8 years and it can't change now. Please understand. It's not like that in the books..... and we ARE based on the books. I mean, maybe a 'Minor Water God' Cabin would be more fitting, but putting them in Poseidon cabin would really affect the other big 3 gods and such. Brontes in Zeus, Other water gods in Poseidon, Thanatos(sp) in Hades? Doesn't really work like that in my opinion.